Etsy Price Guide
Cookies
Cookies ACEOs are a curated corner of Etsy. Most shops here list a card or two at a time, so the work speaks for itself and a premium price sticks when the card earns it.
At a Glance
- Median Price
- $10
- P25 Price
- $4
- lower bound
- P75 Price
- $49
- upper bound
- Heat
- 9
- 10+ favorers
Based on 46 priced listings on Etsy.
Analysis
Reading the Cookies market on Etsy
Right now 27 shops are listing, 74.1% of them with a single card up. The top shop holds 26.1% of what is listed.
The middle of the market sits at $10. Most cards list between $4 and $49. Over the last 89 days the typical price has been sliding, from $14.95 to $10. Price inside that band unless you have a clear reason to sit above it: signed, numbered, or a name collectors already chase.
Few listings are marked one of a kind, so leaning into originals is a real differentiator. Nearly every listing is tagged handmade, so that tag alone will not set you apart on this shelf. 9 listings already have ten or more favorers, so there are buyers watching this theme.
In a curated market, the card sells the price. Make something worth the number.
Price Trend (Etsy vs eBay)
The daily median price for Cookies ACEOs.
Signals and Character
What this theme rewards
Collectibility signals
- Handmade
- 95.7%
- OOAK
- 2.2%
- Signed
- 4.3%
Rates at which sellers tag listings as original/handmade art on Etsy.
Market character
Curated
Scarce, OOAK-heavy listings. High pricing power for original work.
- Unique Shops
- 27
- Single-Listing Shops
- 74.1%
- Top Shop Share
- 26.1%
Supply
Shop competition
The shops with the most active listings in this theme right now.
| Shop | Listings | Avg Price |
|---|---|---|
| evelampia | 12 | $50.67 |
| nostalgicrosestudio | 3 | $2.43 |
| likeinkdrops | 3 | $3.3 |
| rytasartworld | 2 | $9 |
| artrium | 2 | $2.99 |
| paintyourdreamshop | 2 | $57.5 |
| dragonstreasurehunt | 2 | $70 |
| bowandvineboutique | 1 | $8 |
Top Favorited Live Listings
Stay in the Know
Newsletter
Updates straight to your inbox.